Donald Trump can't block people on Twitter, judge rules

Trump's all-powerful Twitter reign is over

In New York Southern District the US District Judge Naomi Reice Buchwald gave her decision on a petition registered by a group of seven followers who claimed that President Trump illegally blocked them from viewing his feed.

"My concern at the time, was this guy, with so much responsibility, who has all the nuclear codes, is so careless with a platform that is so powerful that he makes typos and doesn't care about it", Gu said Wednesday. A Twitter-wide ban cuts users off from the feeds of public figures with even more finality than a block.

The Justice Department has argued that Trump was acting in a personal capacity by blocking critics who often used "intentionally inflammatory language".

Gu said he believes he was blocked after responding to a Trump tweet in June 2017 in which the president touted his approval rating in a Rasmussen Poll.

Since then, he has built his following to 52.2 million and added another 3,400 tweets, including major policy and personnel announcements. Rex Tillerson learned he'd been fired from his job as Secretary of State by a tweet from this account, for example.

The court ruled that the people have a right to participate in a "public forum", which applies to social media.

She also pointed out that the National Archives considers @realDonaldTrump an official government document and requires that tweets be preserved as White House records.

"We respectfully disagree with the court's decision and are considering our next steps", Kerri Kupec, Justice Department spokesperson said.

Free speech advocates, though, hailed the ruling.

The ruling is being viewed as a victory for freedom of speech and the public's right to communicate opposing political views directly to elected officials and government agencies.

Anyone, regardless of whether they have a Twitter account, can generally view @realDonaldTrump tweets.

JJ Watt visits Santa Fe shooting survivors and nurses at hospital
Tuesday's inaugural session focused on school districts arming teachers and better tracking student mental health. Santa Fe High School is the site of the 22nd school shooting to take place in the United States this year.

It's not clear, as of this writing, how many Twitter users Trump has blocked - it could be a few dozen, it could be thousands.

Buckwalter had replied: "To be fair you didn't win the WH: Russia won it for you".

She was blocked previous year after tweeting to Mr. Trump: "To be fair you didn't win the WH: Russia won it for you".

And because of Trump's actions, the court concludes that the use of the account "is governmental in nature".

"The essence of this ruling is that viewpoint discrimination is prohibited", Calvert said.

A United States district court has ruled that President Donald Trump can not block Twitter users from his account due to their political views.

Judge Buchwald said that the answer to both the questions was no. The court held that the official's Facebook page constituted a public forum and she had therefore violated the First Amendment when she blocked a critical constituent from commenting on it. Because Mr. Trump and Mr. Scavino also retain control over the account, she said, it's a government space as well.

Other media reports said the judge advised Mr Trump to mute critics if he doesn't want to see their activities, but they would be able to see and reply his own tweets.

Buchwald said Trump could opt to mute his critics instead.

"Given that no government office is above the law, we assume that the president and [Daniel] Scavino will remedy the blockade that we have considered unconstitutional", which the plaintiffs have to request to Trump, says Buchwald.

Related News:

  • New census numbers show which Southern Illinois communities are shrinking

    New census numbers show which Southern Illinois communities are shrinking

    The U.S. city that added the most residents between 2016 and 2017 was San Antonio , which boosted its population by 24,208 people. Past year it grew by more than a third of its population, making it the fastest-growing city, town or village in Florida.
    Stephen Curry cooks Rockets as Warriors take 2-1 lead

    Stephen Curry cooks Rockets as Warriors take 2-1 lead

    We've got so many great players on this team that draw attention you've just got to be ready to shoot". Analysis: Just two possessions later, Iguodala's pass to Thompson gets by him, but it looks.
    FDA Approves Non-Opioid Treatment for Opioid Withdrawal

    FDA Approves Non-Opioid Treatment for Opioid Withdrawal

    The guidelines were not well received by patients, who said the guidelines led to less doctors prescribing opioids for their pain. Lucemyra works by reducing the release of norepinephrine, a chemical in the body believed to play a part in withdrawal symptoms.
  • NFL restores respect for national anthem

    NFL restores respect for national anthem

    There is no requirement that players be on the field during the national anthem. "I think the people pushed it forward", he said. On Thursday, perhaps the biggest documented anti-anthem protester, President Trump , weighed in on the NFL's revised policy .
    US employee in China reports mysterious 'abnormal' sounds and pressure

    US employee in China reports mysterious 'abnormal' sounds and pressure

    The US State Department expelled 17 Cuban diplomats from its Washington embassy past year after the incidents came to light. Unlike their American counterparts, however, no Canadian envoy reported hearing any suspicious sound prior to falling ill.
    WH Calls Kim Jong-Un 'Supreme Leader' On Peace Summit Challenge Coin

    WH Calls Kim Jong-Un 'Supreme Leader' On Peace Summit Challenge Coin

    Trump" and "Supreme Leader Kim Jong-Un" in front of their respective national flags and the words "peace talks". The list was resubmitted on Monday, but was swiftly rejected by North Korea once again.
  • Venezuela throws out U.S.  diplomats for

    Venezuela throws out U.S. diplomats for "conspiracies"

    Maduro promised to present "evidence" that both diplomats were engaged in a political, military and economic "conspiracy". President Trump signed a new order which prevents American companies from buying debt from Venezuela .
    Revamped YouTube Music Free and Premium Launches Tues

    Revamped YouTube Music Free and Premium Launches Tues

    YouTube Premium includes ad-free background and offline access to YouTube and YouTube Originals, on top of YouTube Music Premium . According to Recode , YouTube Music will eventually replace Google Play Music , Google's very similar music streaming service .
    Italy's 5-Star, League on Verge of Government Deal; Markets Shudder

    Italy's 5-Star, League on Verge of Government Deal; Markets Shudder

    Mattarella. "The spread is going up - do you remember the spread?" he said in a live. The policy programme will probably be published on Thursday, 5-Star said.
  • Season ends for top-seeded women's golf after upset by Arizona

    Season ends for top-seeded women's golf after upset by Arizona

    In the quarterfinals against UCLA, Pagdanganan won her match 1 up, her birdie on the 18th hole sending Arizona to the next round. Moore would win the 17th, and headed to the 18th with a stroke lead, hoping to secure the schools' third championship.
    Indian police face fury over shooting deaths of 10 protesters

    Indian police face fury over shooting deaths of 10 protesters

    The government, underlining its "pro-people commitment", said further legal action would be taken, "respecting" their feelings. The protestors claimed that that the plant would pollute groundwater in their area, and causing serious environmental hazards.
    The Pope says God makes some people gay. Now get over it.

    The Pope says God makes some people gay. Now get over it.

    But his latest remark, if accurate, would mark an historic shift in attitudes towards homosexuality within the Catholic church. Mr Cruz spoke of his happiness after receiving a personal apology from Pope Francis for the abuse that he suffered.


Most liked

American Legion to host Memorial Day ceremony
The parade will begin at 10 a.m. and traverse Grand Ave. with veterans, service groups, horses and lots of patriotism. At 11:30 a.m., there will be an open house for all veterans and their families at the new Veterans Center at 311 N.

Michael Cohen: I'm Friend And Client Of Taxi King - But Not Partner
At this point, Michael Cohen , the only thing he can do to save himself from going to jail, because this guy, Mr. Friedman's attorney, Patrick Egan, declined to discuss whether Friedman's plea spells trouble for Cohen.

Hawaii volcano fissures MAP: How many fissures are active at Kilauea volcano?
Scientists say lava from Kilauea volcano in Hawaii is causing fireworks-like explosions as it enters the ocean. Kilauea is one of the most active volcanoes in the world and one of five on the Big Island of Hawaii .

Ariana Grande sends love to Manchester one year after attack
Members of the public also watched the proceedings on screen at York Minster, Liverpool Metropolitan Cathedral and Glasgow Cathedral.

'American Idol' finale ends with a twist
The couple then performed a medley of "Somewhere Over the Rainbow" and "What a Wonderful World". 'MY GIRLFRIEND WON AMERICAN IDOL!' he tweeted that night.

M&S to Close More Than 100 Stores Amid Online Push
Marks & Spencer has seen full-year profits collapse as the high street giant counts the cost of a brutal store closure plan. However, shares in M&S were up 4.5% at 304.90 pence on Wednesday, having hit a high of 311.00p earlier in the session.

Markets rise as Beijing and Washington avert trade war
Last month, the administration proposed tariffs on $50 billion of Chinese imports to protest the forced technology transfers. A week ago, Trump tweeted that he was working with Chinese President Xi Jinping to put ZTE "back in business, fast".

Iran calls for respecting Venezuelan election's results
There is no indication in the statement that the Lima Group countries will permanently pull their ambassadors from Caracas . Calling for a new vote, Mr Falcon, 56, said: "The process undoubtedly lacks legitimacy and as such we do not recognise it".

Things We Learned from the Black Ops 4 Reveal Event
There's one in a gladiator arena and another on a cruise ship that appears to be the Titanic, and it's all very confusing. Their tools can set enemy players ablaze, protect an area with razor wire, or give health to nearby teammates.

Oil prices move further upward
Oil traded near $71 a barrel as rising stockpiles and signs of slower demand growth countered concerns Iranian supplies will soon be curbed by sanctions.

Senate votes to restore net neutrality
Neither tipped a hand until they voted a few hours earlier Wednesday to move the measure past a procedural hurdle. The topic of net neutrality was also used to make some astute observations about broader America.

Egypt's Sisi orders Gaza border opened for Ramadan: Twitter account
It says those approaching the fence have used explosive devices and firebombs, while soldiers have been shot at. Israel said it was acting in self-defense and showed evidence that many of those killed were Hamas operatives .

'Disgusted' officials file complaint against man for anti-immigrant rant
Schlossberg did not return calls to his home and office and emails from ABC News seeking comment. And reviewers on Google suggested his law firm be identified as a " Mexican restaurant ".

Gina Haspel confirmed as CIA's first female director
Since Trump nominated Haspel, her confirmation has been clouded by debate over the CIA's former interrogation program. Republican Senator John McCain , who is undergoing cancer treatment outside of Washington , did not vote.

More Scenes From Last Night's Deadly Thunderstorms & The Aftermath
Winds along parts of Northeast reached up to 150 miles per hour knocking down power poles and many trees, CNN forecasters said. Connecticut State Police also confirmed that someone in New Fairfield was killed after a tree landed on their vehicle .